Okay, no offence taken neways. its a healthy discussion here bro. I am all chill.
waise gst is chargeable on top of market price. so if u bought gold coin at 6K+3% gst = 6180, so when u try to sell the same coin on same day at any other shop, u shd get approx 5900-5950.
U wnt get GST part and around 50-100 lesser, now in case if u sell same coin on any other day when price has slightly dropped, say that day market price is 5900, then u wld get around 5800 or so.
This is what my experience is and i am surprised gold coin or bars are being charged making charges, which is unheard of. neways local jeweller might be trying to misguide u if he is saying making charges deduct honge on gold coins or bars.
All big and small shops here do charge making charges. It's not new here. I think the making charge is less if you purchase 5+ grams of gold coin. But there is making charge for sure on gold coins in every shop in Mumbai. It is a given that they will charge. It's not about one jeweller. All of them charge making charges here. You won't get it at market rates here. Jewellery making charges are different. That is even more costly.