bldc fans comparison ( Crompton VS Atomberg )

295°
Deal Newbie
raj__raj

Crompton Energion HS 1200 mm Energy Efficient 5 Star (https://www.amazon.in/Crompton-Energion-HS-Opal...)

vs

Atomberg Efficio 1200mm 28W BLDC Energy Saving 5 Star Rated (https://www.amazon.in/Gorilla-Energy-Saving-Cei...)

warrenty

Crompton – 5 years

Atomberg -  3 years

Amazon rating

Crompton – 4 star

Atomberg -4.3 star

Price

Crompton – ₹3,287

Atomberg – ₹3,400

is Atomberg Renesa better than above mentioned variants? Or any other competitive models?

Any HELP – deciding between two? Anyone using these or has any comments??


Expiring In 16 days
52 Comments  |  
20 Dimers
  • Sort By
Rajasthan Royals Rajasthan Royals
Link Copied

crompton

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
Cool07 wrote:

crompton

are you using this model or any other crompton model?

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied

Atomberg fans require constant repair. They make noise after sometime. They are rated good because they were first to market and cutting our bills to half.

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
abhishekkjain wrote:

Atomberg fans require constant repair. They make noise after sometime. They are rated good because they were first to market and cutting our bills to half.

which Atomberg fan do you use? and since when?
any other recommendation?

Chennai Super Kings Chennai Super Kings
Link Copied

atomberg making tooooo much clicking sound from blades and we can’t even sleep. Technician assigned but no one came yet. It’s soo annoying. I have renesa plus btw. My friend is having the same problem.

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
chota_chattri wrote:

atomberg making tooooo much clicking sound from blades and we can’t even sleep. Technician assigned but no one came yet. It’s soo annoying. I have renesa plus btw. My friend is having the same problem.

Did you start facing this problem after few months of purchase or right from the start? Whats the age of the device?

Chennai Super Kings Chennai Super Kings
Link Copied
Expand
raj__raj wrote:

Did you start facing this problem after few months of purchase or right from the start? Whats the age of the device?

delivered on april 19, 2022.

Complaint raised – May 8, 2022

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

Been using atomberg renesa and renesa+ for 6 months and no issues so far 🤞.

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
PabloEscobar wrote:

Been using atomberg renesa and renesa+ for 6 months and no issues so far 🤞.

any idea about crompton? or any recommended model?

Deal Subedar Deal Subedar
Link Copied
PabloEscobar wrote:

Been using atomberg renesa and renesa+ for 6 months and no issues so far 🤞.

what’s the difference between these two?

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied
Expand
raj__raj wrote:

which Atomberg fan do you use? and since when?
any other recommendation?

Atomberg effico+ and studio. Been more than 1 year. Can’t recommend as I only have atomberg fans.

Mumbai Indians Mumbai Indians
Link Copied
abhishekkjain wrote:

Atomberg fans require constant repair. They make noise after sometime. They are rated good because they were first to market and cutting our bills to half.

I have been using Atomberg BLDC fan since 4-5 years, had 3 years warranty.


No problems till date.


If you get clicking sounds, stop cleaning the blades with force and bending them.


I clean the blades myself, not one sound from the fan in 5 years.


Bought fan for only 1700 as part of TATA Power DSM program, that program is still going on.

Once mom lifted something amazon box or something and it hit the fan, it started making noise because the blades got bent, raised a request, blades were changes next day, problem fixed. Service good in Mumbai since company is mumbai based, and service in Mumbai is provided directly by company. In other states, it might be 3rd party service.

No problems since that day, its been years.

Firestorm Firestorm
Link Copied

atomberg mtlb chalti firti train ho gayi hai ab 🤣🤭 . Quality bhot down ho gaya hai last 1 year se. Hr ek 5 users me se 3 users ko sound ka problem aa rhe hai . 

abhi jo log bol rhe koi problem nahi hua last 2-3 years se , wo sab ne 2021 se pehele liye huye fans Hain jyadatr gorilla best tha quality me. 

koi bhi bldc fan lelo sab me yahi problem aayega . Tier 1/2 se ho , atomberg ka service accha hai to renesa lena chahiye . Power consumption dono ka 33-35w rhega top speed pr 28w just marketing gimmick


Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied
onlineuser7 wrote:

atomberg mtlb chalti firti train ho gayi hai ab 🤣🤭 . Quality bhot down ho gaya hai last 1 year se. Hr ek 5 users me se 3 users ko sound ka problem aa rhe hai . 

abhi jo log bol rhe koi problem nahi hua last 2-3 years se , wo sab ne 2021 se pehele liye huye fans Hain jyadatr gorilla best tha quality me. 

koi bhi bldc fan lelo sab me yahi problem aayega . Tier 1/2 se ho , atomberg ka service accha hai to renesa lena chahiye . Power consumption dono ka 33-35w rhega top speed pr 28w just marketing gimmick


Good information provided
KG

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied

Using Efficio model since April 2022, initially some humming noise while rotating, now seems okay. Remote response 7/10 clicks. Yet to get electricity bill to verify actual consumption.

Deal Subedar Deal Subedar
Link Copied

i have Crompton brought for 2200 in bbd 2019.

infrared receiver on fan is on upper side of fan so you need to stand and point in right direction to make it work. 

sometimes fan restart itself. However at top speed it restarts too frequently. So i use it max at speed 4.

in my opinion fan manufacturers should set speed according to rpm rather wattage. So that during voltage fluctuations speed remains same, I think dc fans can do that. 

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied
Expand
neo_t wrote:

I have been using Atomberg BLDC fan since 4-5 years, had 3 years warranty.


No problems till date.


If you get clicking sounds, stop cleaning the blades with force and bending them.


I clean the blades myself, not one sound from the fan in 5 years.


Bought fan for only 1700 as part of TATA Power DSM program, that program is still going on.

Once mom lifted something amazon box or something and it hit the fan, it started making noise because the blades got bent, raised a request, blades were changes next day, problem fixed. Service good in Mumbai since company is mumbai based, and service in Mumbai is provided directly by company. In other states, it might be 3rd party service.

No problems since that day, its been years.

Bearing are getting replaced for 4 of 12 fans I have. These are anti dust fans doesn’t require much cleaning. Just dry cloth smooth rub does the job.

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied
Expand
neo_t wrote:

I have been using Atomberg BLDC fan since 4-5 years, had 3 years warranty.


No problems till date.


If you get clicking sounds, stop cleaning the blades with force and bending them.


I clean the blades myself, not one sound from the fan in 5 years.


Bought fan for only 1700 as part of TATA Power DSM program, that program is still going on.

Once mom lifted something amazon box or something and it hit the fan, it started making noise because the blades got bent, raised a request, blades were changes next day, problem fixed. Service good in Mumbai since company is mumbai based, and service in Mumbai is provided directly by company. In other states, it might be 3rd party service.

No problems since that day, its been years.

Please let me know what is TATA Power DSM and how to get it so cheap! I got it at twice the price.

Sunrisers Hyderabad Sunrisers Hyderabad
Link Copied

Bought atomberg renesa for 2.4k on pepperfry few months ago. No problem so far

Commentator Commentator
Link Copied

Been using atomberg renesa+ for 7 months, no issues so far.

Community Angel Community Angel
Link Copied
Raman997 wrote:

Been using atomberg renesa+ for 7 months, no issues so far.

how are you using it from past 7 months kya December and January mein bhi pankha chala rahe the kya smile

Community Angel Community Angel
Link Copied

bhaiyo bahno mere pas ek BLDC ka 12 volt 20 watt ka ceiling fan hai very good air using from past two years on 50 watt solar plate in daylight(matlab din ka bill zero) and in night inverter battery se kya ismein koi electric circuit laga kar 220v se Direct chalaya jaye to bill kam ayega bad thing is ye fan start hone ke liye full power (jerk) mangta hai such ceiling fans are available at around 1300-1500 Rs. in market kahi se atombom fan ka dc circuit mil sakta hai kya isme laga kar try karna tha shayad saste mein jugaad lag jaye 

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
onlineuser7 wrote:

atomberg mtlb chalti firti train ho gayi hai ab 🤣🤭 . Quality bhot down ho gaya hai last 1 year se. Hr ek 5 users me se 3 users ko sound ka problem aa rhe hai . 

abhi jo log bol rhe koi problem nahi hua last 2-3 years se , wo sab ne 2021 se pehele liye huye fans Hain jyadatr gorilla best tha quality me. 

koi bhi bldc fan lelo sab me yahi problem aayega . Tier 1/2 se ho , atomberg ka service accha hai to renesa lena chahiye . Power consumption dono ka 33-35w rhega top speed pr 28w just marketing gimmick


translation pls 😬

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
chota_chattri wrote:

atomberg making tooooo much clicking sound from blades and we can’t even sleep. Technician assigned but no one came yet. It’s soo annoying. I have renesa plus btw. My friend is having the same problem.

are you referring to this kind of noise?


This is unbearable!

Chennai Super Kings Chennai Super Kings
Link Copied
Expand
raj__raj wrote:

are you referring to this kind of noise?


This is unbearable!

yes and in mine it’s more frequent. I mean if in the video the tiktik sound occured 100 times in a minute then in mine it’s 250 times per minute. It’s really annoying, but in boost mode it’s working fine. So we had to open the fan in full speed only. We can’t use it in the month of march and october I guess😂

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
neehesh wrote:

Bought atomberg renesa for 2.4k on pepperfry few months ago. No problem so far

any offer running on pepperfry right now? under what offer did you buy?

Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
jambui wrote:

i have Crompton brought for 2200 in bbd 2019.

infrared receiver on fan is on upper side of fan so you need to stand and point in right direction to make it work. 

sometimes fan restart itself. However at top speed it restarts too frequently. So i use it max at speed 4.

in my opinion fan manufacturers should set speed according to rpm rather wattage. So that during voltage fluctuations speed remains same, I think dc fans can do that. 

auto restart of fan is just not acceptable? Do you face frequent voltage fluctuations?

Kolkata Knight Riders Kolkata Knight Riders
Link Copied
jambui wrote:

i have Crompton brought for 2200 in bbd 2019.

infrared receiver on fan is on upper side of fan so you need to stand and point in right direction to make it work. 

sometimes fan restart itself. However at top speed it restarts too frequently. So i use it max at speed 4.

in my opinion fan manufacturers should set speed according to rpm rather wattage. So that during voltage fluctuations speed remains same, I think dc fans can do that. 

What do you mean you need to stand and point at the fan? WTF. I can’t stay on bed, all laid back and point the remote at the fan to make it work? I have to get up from bed and stand up for that? This is most comical if true.

replyuser
Click here to reply
Reply