Do you like DesiDime's new comment section ?
Poll has expired, here are the final results
Hot Deal

DesiDime's new comment section is the worst

891°
Finance Ninja
abhishek012

DesiDime's new comment section is the worst 😬

Bas itna he bolna tha. 😄

I don't usually complain about anything but this time all limits have been crossed 😬(just kidding).

Kuch smajh nhi aa raha hai, kon kidhar comment kar raha hai. 😄

Notification option k link se page kahi aur he open ho raha hai.

Got this notification - "@freedealexpert mentioned you in a comment"

Ok and when i click on the link -

this page is open -

comment

I don't know in which comment he mentioned me 👆🏼

when i click on both the view more replies option.

Now it's surprising that his comment was not found in either of them.

Now after clicking on View More Reply option of all comments, I got his reply below the last comment.

Simple sa comment section ko itna complicated kar diya hai.

The most irritating part is that from now on we will have to keep clicking on View More Reply option on all comments.

Top Comments
Analyst Analyst
Link Copied

The redirection sucks due to incorrect page number. For example, comment id is 9834567 and it's on page 3 (but when copied/notified from/by Desidime, it's by default picking up page1 and not the actual page where comment is present.) it's showing ?page1#post_9834567 instead of (correct one) ?page3#post_9834567
Fwd: @droid @amit.saha @bumblefoot

Finance Mentor Finance Mentor
Link Copied

@bumblefoot please ask devs to give us an option for flat threads. If you guys think the current one is better, surely keep it default. But please let us change.

@admin

Generous Generous
Link Copied

DD is behaving like Nirmla Sitaraman / BJP... jo marzi bolo.. hum to wohi karenge jo hum chahte hai ..

It is community which makes DD live.. please do listen to them.

57 Comments  |  
41 Dimers
  • Sort By
Pro Community Angel Pro Community Angel
Link Copied

+1

Most probably its not fully developed.

Benevolent Benevolent
Link Copied

It keeps getting worse all the time. 

Benevolent Benevolent
Link Copied
have some faith
View 2 more replies
Analyst Analyst
Link Copied

The redirection sucks due to incorrect page number. For example, comment id is 9834567 and it's on page 3 (but when copied/notified from/by Desidime, it's by default picking up page1 and not the actual page where comment is present.) it's showing ?page1#post_9834567 instead of (correct one) ?page3#post_9834567
Fwd: @droid @amit.saha @bumblefoot

Generous Generous
Admin
Link Copied
team is working on it brother.. everything will be fixed.
View 1 more reply
Generous Generous
Link Copied

Is this user-specific? On the Web, nothing has changed for me 😬

Deal's Advocate Deal's Advocate
Link Copied
Ab Desidime ke under bhi User Specific hone laga kya 😂
😂😂
Deal Detective Deal Detective
Link Copied

Even group  notification   same  problem  . Notification   deal  us different   and  we  land  in  different  deal , also at times it freezes .

Also  Deal sharing link is for whatsapp   and  email now in app as of today i checked , how to copy deal link to forward in dm than.

Generous Generous
Link Copied

Mein toh complain karna hi chhor diya.. From last 1 month there is redirecting issue. In opera mini, it always popsup security check or something similar sh*t. I've to click address bar and manually remove prefixed desidime url to visit the page., due to this they may be losing some affiliate earnings as well...

Its been a month! Comeon..

Blaze Blaze
Link Copied

Yes it's worst on web version. In app it's old style only

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

Let's move to another self hosted forum service.

Lets users use their own affiliate link. Let them earn.

It's just about taking initiative.

To admin/mods-

image


EDIT1 - 

Fun fact- Admin/Mod removed the main part of my comment, so pity. And to @Garyhost babaji reddit ab mainstream mein aa gaya hai, and there's endless possibilities of creating a self sustainable healthy ecosystem for the present dimers. Hard pill to swallow, 



Another YouTube short to mod and admin-



Helpful Helpful
Link Copied

You can create but Moderation and Site charges will be there. 

View 1 more reply
Helpful Helpful
Link Copied

I am also frustrated with this.

And I was taken decision to leave desidime also.

But some people like @kartikxxx demotivated and told me to leave and some motivated and I stayed. 

Personally I also didn't liked new comment section..

Please bring previous system back. 

@admin

Benevolent Benevolent
Link Copied

I think it's under maintenance or major upgradation.

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

Wait a minute 😄 this new comment section looks clean and organised to me. Idhar v problem he guys ? 😜

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied
Exactly, I also thought it is much better now as we can see who all commented at one place itself, redirection issue is temporary and can be resolved but this feature is really good. 
Earlier I used to get confused where my comment went especially on very active topics. Now it seems lot more organized. 
Deal Captain Deal Captain
Link Copied

Thank God nobody tags me kissing_smiling_eyes

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied

Whenever any changes happen in UI, People in Desidime to Admin be like:

“Your job, throughout your entire life, is to disappoint as many people as it takes to avoid disappointing yourself.”

― Glennon Doyle, Untamed

Deal's Advocate Deal's Advocate
Link Copied

Thank God Someone Spoke about it. I myself was baffled by this new UI (looks cringy) 
Sometimes the font changes sometimes it makes all Bold when commenting 
Sometimes I don't see what I commented & at other times I keep on liking a comment thousand times but it doesn't shows up

image


Initially I thought  to restart PC (old school solution) as I am on Web version but then found a weird solution

I post/like or comment and Get that link & open up in a new Browser without Signing in to see the older version of the UI

🙆‍♀️ 😣😂

Pro Shopping Friend Pro Shopping Friend
Link Copied

There's an old saying - If it ain't broke don't fix it.

Desidime played Uno Reverse - We break & then fix it.

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied

for me, each comment is opening in browser.

How can i fix it

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied

hotukdeals walon ne bhi aisa hi raita failaya hua hai unki website pe! Unki commecnts section bhi aisi hi hai!

Deal Subedar Deal Subedar
Link Copied

New comment section just started only, it should take time as new things take time to develop. Yes, feedback is equally important.

Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied

Old=Gold

Finance Ninja Finance Ninja
Link Copied

@Best_Deal_Hunter @Tera_Jija

No, i disagree. Now the comments are being hidden. If you want to find some important comment or images.

And you don't remember who did it.

You need to click on all comments "View More Reply option" to find the image and msgs.

Earlier we used to search or find it very easily.

for example here someone posted an image for a PinePerks Physical RuPay Card - https://www.desidime.com/deals/10k-rupay-gift-c...

I don't remember who's that guy.

Now I have to click on View More Reply option of all comments to find that image.

Earlier it was find very easily only by scrolling from top to bottom.

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied
Bro, there could be some bugs here and there, which will take a few days to resolve. 
Anyways there could be positives and negatives of any new system plus nobody likes change. 
let's list point by point if you think something can be improved or not working in new system to make it better for everyone.
View 1 more reply
Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied
Comment No Longer Exist
Pro Analyst Pro Analyst
Link Copied

Bro, what you're doing comes under spamming - posting similar comments in multiple unrelated threads.

Avoid spamming, or else your account will be suspended on DD.

Cc. @admin @Rosh_0007 @James_012

Benevolent Benevolent
Link Copied

desktop mey v ab aagyaa yea .

Helpful Helpful
Link Copied

now this is on desktop also...

difficult to track others important quoted comments on older pages.. sad

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

they want us to stop using desidime.  its impossible to track what has been posted. How difficult was to not touch what was perfectly working fine.  should I keep on shuffling the page to see comments on older post, Straight away made live without getting user feedback

Finance Ninja Finance Ninja
Link Copied
Yes. Now unable to find some important comments or images posted on the comment section.

@Rosh_0007 bring back old comment section.
View 1 more reply
Finance Mentor Finance Mentor
Link Copied

@bumblefoot please ask devs to give us an option for flat threads. If you guys think the current one is better, surely keep it default. But please let us change.

@admin

Critic Critic
Link Copied

Its been 6 months! comment section is still very tricky and confusing. We essentially have few choices:

1) bring back flat thread as suggested by @abhishek012 OP bro and others

2) have toggle option to show flat thread (same like 'top comments' toggle option) as suggested by @Seinfeld

3) if above not possible, then at least have have toggle option to disclose all comments on thread... no need to waste time clicking 'view xyz replies' to see those hidden comments

Please do something 🙏🙏🙏

@bumblefoot sir @Rosh_0007 @Mayavi @quantum

Analyst Analyst
Link Copied



https:/...ic.
Generous Generous
Link Copied

DD is behaving like Nirmla Sitaraman / BJP... jo marzi bolo.. hum to wohi karenge jo hum chahte hai ..

It is community which makes DD live.. please do listen to them.

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

When something is not broken... don't fix it.

Deal Subedar Deal Subedar
Link Copied

View 0 more reply

Finance Ninja Finance Ninja
Link Copied

@admin @anthrax.ut At least listen to the members sometime.

Or is your investor (https://peppe...m/) forcing to have such a comment section ? 😬

Because all https://peppe...m/ shopping community has the same comment section.

Tell your investors, India is a unique market. What works successfully in another country may not necessarily work in India.

I used other https://pepper.com/ com...ty sites, there are not that many members commenting there.

Look at the population of India. There are so many comments that it is impossible to click on "View More Reply" on each comments.

replyuser
Click here to reply
Reply