LIC Annuity Policy - Should I surrender?

71°
Heart of Gold
jainashish85

I have X amount LIC jeevan shanti annuity plan in my mother's name (age 60) with annuity of 5.63%, this was taken 5 years ago.

Current surrender value is ~85% of policy value, so I will lose 15% of the capital.

This annuity is fully taxable at slab rate, no income tax benefit as well.

I can do a senior citizen FD which would yield 9% returns.

With my calculations if I take the hit of 15% surrender value and invest the amount in above FD then after 5 years I will make more than 5.63%. If the returns are better 10-12% then the time period reduces to 4 years.

I have almost made up my mind to surrender it as the return on this plan will be constant 5.63 and will never change.

IMO it is better to exit from an bad investment rather than stick with it and fuel further losses.

Want to hear from others if I should consider any other angles before i surrender?

Disclaimer
We are not SEBI/IRDA registered. The information provided herein is for education purposes only. We will not be responsible for any of your profit/loss with this channel's suggestions. Consult your financial advisor before making any decisions.
17 Comments  |  
6 Dimers
  • Sort By
Investor Guru Investor Guru
Link Copied
  • If you have the confidence that you will be able to make more returns then yes please proceed with surrender
  • Another option is you make this policy paid up. Calculate the maturity of the paid-up policy time & return with FD with surrender value. 

Wingman Wingman
Link Copied

* A 5 yr tax free fd at any bank is available @ 8.5-9%

Index fund can give 12% average, opt elss for tax

* Surrender full instead of making paid up coz only 5yrs passed and this policy is for life time of user. Use the surrendered money and invest in any low expense index fund.

Lic has xxxxxcrores unclaimed policy return coz people did lic and died and no one left to claim / don't know if can claim

View 2 more replies
Deal Cadet Deal Cadet
Link Copied

you are just looking at 5.63% return. Share other details like are you going to get the X amount back at the end.

Heart of Gold Heart of Gold
Link Copied

This is annuity plan so I will get the same amount I have invested, no bonus in this policy.

It is fixed return.

View 10 more replies
Heart of Gold Heart of Gold
Link Copied

Update: I calculated the surrender from calculators available on internet, so my calculations were based on 85% surrender value.
Today I visited LIC office and got the surrender value of LIC policy, to mu surprise it is a whooping cut of 27%, so I get only ~73% back.

With this new surrender value, I am thinking to continue the policy as it would take a good 10 years to break even.
Below is my calculation, pleae review and comment if there is any incorrect in my calculation.


Ann ROI Expexted ROI
5.63 9
Current Annuity Surrendrer Annuity Plan Surrender Plan
Year 1000000 727700
1 56300 65493 1056300 793193
2 59470 71387 1115770 864580
3 62818 77812 1178588 942393
4 66354 84815 1244942 1027208
5 70090 92449 1315032 1119657
6 74036 100769 1389069 1220426
7 78205 109838 1467273 1330264
8 82607 119724 1549881 1449988
9 87258 130499 1637139 1580487
10 92171 142244 1729310 1722731
11 97360 155046 1826670 1877776
replyuser
Click here to reply
Reply