Annual Appraisal (Review/Ratings) of Admins

Annual Appraisal (Review/Ratings) of Admins

705°
Lord snow
Deal Lieutenant
3
107
4319
37

We are already into New Financial Year, and at the end of each year all corporates do a analysis of their Management on the basis of Peer Review and User Review.

Shouldn’t we have same system of Annual Appraisal thread for all our Admins/Moderators/Top Bosses where the General public (Dimers) can rate our Admins/Moderators on a scale of 1-10 and can also provide a subjective feedback on what they did right or wrong? This feedback should be taken constructively to improve the services of DesiDime and to help our Admins in improving their Management and Communication.

So, who are responsible to take it up? Please have a look.

Best Regards https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif

some silent tags here to get suggestion on feasibility and usability of this idea

50 Comments  |  
20 Dimers
Dd
Critic
23
322
15160
229
@JonSnow wrote:

…This feedback should be taken constructively to improve the services and to help our Admins in improving their Management and Communication…



LOL! Good luck with that! https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_toungueout.gif

EDIT: VU n S for the amazing idea. @JonSnow https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_biggrin.gif

CC @DealSeeker

Quote i have failed at times but i never stopped trying rahul dravid 92 90 95
Analyst
109
77
19672
163
@Magus wrote:

@JonSnow wrote:

…This feedback should be taken constructively to improve the services and to help our Admins in improving their Management and Communication…



LOL! Good luck with that! https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_toungueout.gif


+10000

Images
Entertainer
13
0
34056
322

Adminhttps://i.imgur.com/797sMKu.jpg

Lord snow
Deal Lieutenant
3
107
4319
37
@Plato wrote:

Adminhttps://i.imgur.com/797sMKu.jpg


That’s cruel.. Our Admins are not like that… They are nice people.

Fdvdf
suspended
2
153
3292
31
@JonSnow wrote:

@Plato wrote:

Adminhttps://i.imgur.com/797sMKu.jpg


That’s cruel.. Our Admins are not like that… They are nice people.


https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/258852/medium/32749801480959124_9.?1480959129

Lord snow
Deal Lieutenant
3
107
4319
37

Guys, please take it seriously. This can make our DesiDime community much much better.

Fdvdf
suspended
2
153
3292
31
@JonSnow wrote:

Guys, please take it seriously. This can make our DesiDime community much much better.


Admin 2/10

Anthrex 4/10

Nigel 6/10

Bumblefoot 2/10

MJ911 4/10

Matrix stickmen
Perfectionist
30
2,278
42799
735
@JonSnow wrote:

Guys, please take it seriously. This can make our DesiDime community much much better.


I will if you can get an admin to promise that they will take the feedback/suggestions seriously, rather than making a casual acknowledgement post and then forgetting about it (or worse, archiving the entire thread itself!). https://cdn0.desidime.com/smileys/W0iNx.gif

CC @Magus @Spock

Quote i have failed at times but i never stopped trying rahul dravid 92 90 95
Analyst
109
77
19672
163
@DealSeeker wrote:

@JonSnow wrote:

Guys, please take it seriously. This can make our DesiDime community much much better.


I will if you can get an admin to promise that they will take the feedback/suggestions seriously, rather than making a casual acknowledgement post and then forgetting about it (or worse, archiving the entire thread itself!). https://cdn0.desidime.com/smileys/W0iNx.gif

CC @Magus @Spock


As usual with you, completely nailed it!

286 907
Deal Major
1
12
28544
182

@JonSnow vu. good idea bro…. but this shd be done by management. As this community is user driven, they have to ask us feedback of each and every admins, mods…. how management is deciding whether admins/mods are doing proper work or not… dimers r fighting for fpd, favouring the dimers, suspending the users, each and everything shd be according to rule… the rule here is whatever they have done, it is correct https://cdn3.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_cool.gif

Draw
Blogger
10
1,196
56850
1158

I presume 10 is the best rating , will 9 to desi team,
No Ind. Scores unless we know there constraints and we actually have incomplete picture of efforts handled as per there roles.

9 have given based upon continued efforts to improve dd , while they Dont have much competition in India in similar category. 1 mark deducted for not having priorities or well defined policies for rules or transparency. In fact I think they have gone overboard discussion due to compelling by diners or continued pings. They should act unbiased and act based upon transparent policies. I have suggested red card , yellow card for offenders . Similarly fpd once declined should be stated with hint of non accepting or fpd should be given based upon reason so that others can learn the reasoning in positive way !

Mods/ admins can be rated based upon communication or giving unbiased opinion. But it is unlikely for me to ignore the personal rapport hence not rating them.

However, should appreciate the following
@Glp for background work and engagement in dimer’s mother case.

@Beinghuman
To welcome as mod and proving his tolerance towards us. (Refined sugar)

@RDX for not blasting and @Achilles for being connected. @goss8877 for absence. @DealSeeker for becoming smart.

@A2Zdeals for fresh air, @prebhartia for being jhansi ki rani @sbdtrial for semi- retirement.

@marketdimer for not changing dp, @Atlantic for not changing passion but katty for not bringing quiz’s. @usa11 for invisible like @Plato , whereas @Plato do act as lapsing fever and @asoka fever don’t leave him.

@DAN @poopya @Spock for keeping silence here. @[email protected]@ for bringing crude fantasy here. @@[email protected]@ @@[email protected]@ for budding star.

@mahidada sometimes act hyper / emotional but I still enjoy his presence.

@asm123 for aseem sambhavma. @@[email protected]@ @devashi for being frank and active.

Dd
Critic
23
322
15160
229
@DealSeeker wrote:

I will if you can get an admin to promise that they will take the feedback/suggestions seriously, rather than making a casual acknowledgement post and then forgetting about it (or worse, archiving the entire thread itself!). https://cdn0.desidime.com/smileys/W0iNx.gif

CC @Magus @Spock



If I were to do appraisals, they would even make un-professional remarks like… Hey, I know your past ( as if I have changed now! That’s a different story )… https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_toungueout.gif

CC @nsinghal

Kim lee
Deal Lieutenant
4
2
5235
60

@JonSnow

1. Won’t give suggestion for free, and after that credit removal ab toh pakka kuch nahi dene waala
2. My suggestions are worthless, won’t make sense
3. The Legend who is most revered by dimers and admins alike is nailing https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_toungueout.gif

So I am not doing anything. VU for the initiative.

Premam first look.jpg.image.784.410 1491053822386
Entertainer
28
1,240
23642
228
@Magus wrote:
If I were to do appraisals, they would even make un-professional remarks like… Hey, I know your past ( as if I have changed now! That’s a different story )… https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_toungueout.gif

https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/258956/medium/327509110475183_1532757617039322_1589472290_n.jpg?1480959174

Ori
Deal Major
140
214
18030
163

Better open your own DD https://cdn3.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_wink.gif

Img 20150414 215658
Budding Star
46
196
30562
631
@DealSeeker wrote:

@JonSnow wrote:

Guys, please take it seriously. This can make our DesiDime community much much better.


I will if you can get an admin to promise that they will take the feedback/suggestions seriously, rather than making a casual acknowledgement post and then forgetting about it (or worse, archiving the entire thread itself!). https://cdn0.desidime.com/smileys/W0iNx.gif

CC @Magus @Spock


https://i.imgur.com/TzSIwNQ.jpg

Open uri20161119 27009 2xv7rv
Deal Captain
0
276
10793
168
@DealSeeker wrote:

@JonSnow wrote:

Guys, please take it seriously. This can make our DesiDime community much much better.


I will if you can get an admin to promise that they will take the feedback/suggestions seriously, rather than making a casual acknowledgement post and then forgetting about it (or worse, archiving the entire thread itself!). https://cdn0.desidime.com/smileys/W0iNx.gif

CC @Magus @Spock

i am just responding to tags after logging in now, not really gone through the whole context of things.
[and responding despite trying to force myself not to respond as i only create irritants to the people here, right @desidimes https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_confused.gif ]

to tell you frankly, i only went through the main post a bit and this post of DS and do not know the conversation yet.

seeing @Magus ‘suggest’ this topic and see what DS said.. i can only do the symbolic ‘hats-off’ to you three fine men.

off late, i only take DD at its face value (which is NOT much) and do not really keep high expectations off it either.

ab woh junoon nahi raha.
[and may be, partially my admiration out of awe here is for people like these > http://www.desidime.com/forums/dost-and-dimes/t... .. which makes DD (administrative staff) look like https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/259202/medium/3275275smallheader.png?1480959281https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/259210/medium/3275275Ducky_Emoticon_by_Spikette2108.gif?1480959283https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/259210/medium/3275275Ducky_Emoticon_by_Spikette2108.gif?1480959283 ]

Open uri20161119 27009 2xv7rv
Deal Captain
0
276
10793
168

@JonSnow @Magus @DealSeeker

more than the hats-off , it is like.. good to see you all still have some ‘hopes’ and ‘expectations’.
.
@JonSnow , remember the Mad Hatter Teat party interaction where
Alice is like I haven’t had any yet, so I can’t very well take more
and the Mad Hatter goes you can always take more than nothing
.
.
where ARE the admins to appraise dear?

I mean, call me dumb, but for their bread and butter Hot Deals, for eternity it was only Bumble bhai (lets exclude the promoter group people or family who are not really admin-admin #youknow)

then came Nigel off late and i dare say how he manages or tackles whatever he does.

MJ911 might be shown as a green boy, but let us (for the moment) not take him as an active employee and let is mysteriousness and helpful nature out of the purview of a scrutiny [i do not think he may really be an employee or even a techie (software related) ]

desi gurl, Priyanka, sara roy .. again do not seem to be be admin-admin .. but .. more like ’ when /if we log in.. we’ll look around..’

and lets also keep tech team employees too out of ‘forum moderation’ appraisal
[if it is for features or lack of them or buggy interface, then yes i might want to put a suhan, hardik, Ankit, Herambh on the grill . not otherwise]
http://pastebin.com/WV...ep

.
.
.
so whats the fun (or risk) in scrutinising just 2-3 employees. i think if i am proved wrong and shown that N (number > 7-8) are exclusively solely responsible for FPD selection, moderation and general up-keep … then may be yes a review/rating.

in two people.. a plus rating to one may discourage (or may even motivate) the other to push the envelop

Open uri20161119 27009 2xv7rv
Deal Captain
0
276
10793
168
@Magus wrote:

@JonSnow wrote:

…This feedback should be taken constructively to improve the services and to help our Admins in improving their Management and Communication…



LOL! Good luck with that! https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_toungueout.gif

EDIT: VU n S for the amazing idea. @JonSnow https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_biggrin.gif

CC @DealSeeker


lol okay.. failed to see this post

the suggestion was underhand satire.. sarcasm https://cdn3.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_lol.gif

Missing
Deal Cadet
0
50
236
0
@Spock wrote:

@DealSeeker wrote:

@JonSnow wrote:

Guys, please take it seriously. This can make our DesiDime community much much better.


I will if you can get an admin to promise that they will take the feedback/suggestions seriously, rather than making a casual acknowledgement post and then forgetting about it (or worse, archiving the entire thread itself!). https://cdn0.desidime.com/smileys/W0iNx.gif

CC @Magus @Spock

i am just responding to tags after logging in now, not really gone through the whole context of things.
[and responding despite trying to force myself not to respond as i only create irritants to the people here, right @desidimes https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_confused.gif ]

to tell you frankly, i only went through the main post a bit and this post of DS and do not know the conversation yet.

seeing @Magus ‘suggest’ this topic and see what DS said.. i can only do the symbolic ‘hats-off’ to you three fine men.

off late, i only take DD at its face value (which is NOT much) and do not really keep high expectations off it either.

ab woh junoon nahi raha.
[and may be, partially my admiration out of awe here is for people like these > http://www.desidime.com/forums/dost-and-dimes/t... .. which makes DD (administrative staff) look like https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/259273/medium/3275307smallheader.png?1480959308https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/259279/medium/3275307Ducky_Emoticon_by_Spikette2108.gif?1480959310https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/259279/medium/3275307Ducky_Emoticon_by_Spikette2108.gif?1480959310 ]


Bhai gum me hai koi daru le kr aao re https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif

Dd
Critic
23
322
15160
229
@Spock wrote:



then came Nigel off late and i dare say how he manages or tackles whatever he does.


https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/259333/medium/3275334Jake-Gyllenhaal-Nightcrawler-GIF-pointing-laughing.gif?1480959333

Open uri20161119 27009 2xv7rv
Deal Captain
0
276
10793
168
@DealSeeker wrote: …that they will take the feedback/suggestions seriously, rather than making a casual acknowledgement post and then forgetting about it..

chha’nch ka jala paani bhi phunk-phunk kar peeta hai.
Tranchlotion: two consecutive years https://cdn3.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_lol.gif [custom badge]

by the way: when they did come up with the ‘junior mod’ badge you’all :LOL: wrinkled you noses so much that Herambh and Ankit had to be given admin responsibilities https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_toungueout.gif
.

.
[ :OOPS: if Herambh and Ankit are reading this, please note that its only a light comment. i DO know some of you are actual back-end people with expertise in mobile technologies or android or whatever mobile applications development and not necessarily forum admins ]

Open uri20161119 27009 2xv7rv
Deal Captain
0
276
10793
168
@tolerable_bhakt wrote: Bhai gum me hai koi daru le kr aao re https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif

i’ll happily take the empty bottles though https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_biggrin.gif
[missed out on even the faltu PP or PET bottle deals off late]
.
.
.
.
.
P.S.: by the way @bhakt.. i hate dislike you . you are just good for guru dev aapke charan kaha hai _ /\ _

kaash aaj @chikni yaha hoti https://cdn3.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_sad.gif woh hoti tou charan tou kya.. woh hamare..
[ @tolerable_bhakt tap/click on @chinni hyper-link above]

Open uri20161119 27009 2xv7rv
Deal Captain
0
276
10793
168
@[email protected]_0_0_D wrote: ..no Individual Scores unless we know their constraints and we actually have incomplete picture of efforts handled as per there roles…

+ 1

@[email protected]_0_0_D wrote: …not having priorities or well defined policies for rules or transparency

+ 1
@[email protected]_0_0_D wrote: ..due to compelling by dimers or continued pings. They should act unbiased and act based upon transparent policies
+ 1
thank you @[email protected]_0_0_D for stating this. so i am not an isolated minority who thinks that the claim of not getting influenced is a wrong claim. https://cdn3.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_sad.gif

CC: @admin , @anthrax.ut SOPs ¿? https://cdn3.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_sad.gif ? the few that are in public domain are neither standard, nor being operated/ adhered to on many occasions.

@[email protected]_0_0_D wrote: I have suggested red card , yellow card for offenders .

+ 1 i remember the earlier instances when you have stated it.
no idea if it is already there in the non public domain accessible only to the admins, Mods and Shri @DimerAbhi .

@[email protected]_0_0_D wrote: so that others can learn the reasoning in positive way !
+ 1

@[email protected]_0_0_D wrote:
But it is unlikely for me to ignore the personal rapport hence not rating them.

+ 1

Missing