Is this fair?

Is this fair?

187°
Missing
Deal Cadet
102
571
8

All our taxes given to UP?https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/614180/original/IMG_20200425_012001.jpg?1587814587

25 Comments  |  
10 Dimers
Missing
Deal Subedar
5
2112
30

Is this tax collected or money given by central government to particular state? Moreover, did you compare UPs population with combined population of these southern states? Where are Maharashtra & Delhi in this list?

Missing
Deal Cadet
102
571
8
sardasa wrote:

Is this tax collected or money given by central government to particular state? Moreover, did you compare UPs population with combined population of these southern states? Where are Maharashtra & Delhi in this list?

I don’t know what kind of taxes they are.. either way not fair. List is just to show UP gets way more than the combined south states. There are few states in the 2k-3k category including Maharashtra, MP.. but all 50% less than UP which gets 8k+

Missing
Blogger
196
1925
54
Expand
Jerry_The_Dimer wrote:

I don’t know what kind of taxes they are.. either way not fair. List is just to show UP gets way more than the combined south states. There are few states in the 2k-3k category including Maharashtra, MP.. but all 50% less than UP which gets 8k+

it’s gst collection share form igst , sgst

Missing
Deal Subedar
5
2112
30
Expand
Jerry_The_Dimer wrote:

I don’t know what kind of taxes they are.. either way not fair. List is just to show UP gets way more than the combined south states. There are few states in the 2k-3k category including Maharashtra, MP.. but all 50% less than UP which gets 8k+

How can central government give tax to any state??

Missing
Deal Major
6,915
23035
280

Not sure if this fair or unfair but this came from INC Social media head
Its like sharing stuff coming from Arnab Goswami or Amit Malviya ..some posts might have credibility/good intentions but majority are politically motivated

Missing
Deal Cadet
140
187
5
sunnysaharan wrote:

Anti national stuff

Centre approves
₹15000 Crore for Covid19 Health Emergency
₹20000 Crore for CentralVista Project
Hope this helps….

Missing
Blogger
1,594
3485
66
Expand
Jerry_The_Dimer wrote:

I don’t know what kind of taxes they are.. either way not fair. List is just to show UP gets way more than the combined south states. There are few states in the 2k-3k category including Maharashtra, MP.. but all 50% less than UP which gets 8k+

Maybe their tax incomes (individual heads) are lower than UP in this particular year. Need more info on this.

Missing
Deal Cadet
102
571
8
Expand
sardasa wrote:

How can central government give tax to any state??

Don’t know..  I’m not an expert in finance. by neft or cheque may be 

Missing
Deal Subedar
5
2112
30
Expand
Jerry_The_Dimer wrote:

Don’t know..  I’m not an expert in finance. by neft or cheque may be 

1st get to the facts of these numbers and then try to judge how fair are they.

Missing
Blogger
1,594
3485
66
getready wrote:

Not sure if this fair or unfair but this came from INC Social media head
Its like sharing stuff coming from Arnab Goswami or Amit Malviya ..some posts might have credibility/good intentions but majority are politically motivated

Yeah, looks like that. BTW, what happened to that Errr Knobhead case? How come DD missed that topic? Lol..

Missing
Deal Cadet
102
571
8
Expand
deb3l wrote:

Maybe their tax incomes (individual heads) are lower than UP in this particular year. Need more info on this.


https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/614181/original/Screenshot_2020-04-25-17-31-41-209_com.google.android.googlequicksearchbox.png?1587816148Overall UP will get 1 lakh 40k crores. 8,255 crores transferred in april. Second in the list is Bihar.

Missing
Critic
373
3268
44

If these are share of GST collections, then pl understand that under GST regime, the State where the final end consumer is gets the maximum share of IGST taxes. It just implies that the consumers of UP buy more from other States.

Missing
Deal Subedar
38
1772
25
Expand
Jerry_The_Dimer wrote:

Yes i will be labelled anti national & arrested

Nice punch 😜, btw why someone need courage to raise this ? obviously It’s not at all fair but who listens.since UP has 80 Lok Sabha constituencies , INC and BJP thinks it’s fair.so,This puzzle is a never ending story.

Missing
Blogger
1,594
3485
66
Expand
Jerry_The_Dimer wrote:


https://cdn0.desidime.com/attachments/photos/614181/original/Screenshot_2020-04-25-17-31-41-209_com.google.android.googlequicksearchbox.png?1587816148Overall UP will get 1 lakh 40k crores. 8,255 crores transferred in april. Second in the list is Bihar.

Why do I smell the beer factor here? grimacing Or any such, those have more tax incomes to centre.

Missing
Deal Major
6,915
23035
280
Expand
deb3l wrote:

Yeah, looks like that. BTW, what happened to that Errr Knobhead case? How come DD missed that topic? Lol..

Wondering the same thing some time back
Even opened political section to see if there’s anything from DD but nothing again smile
Looks like there’s nothing to prove/debate here..

Missing
Community Angel
0
31584
516
Expand
deb3l wrote:

Yeah, looks like that. BTW, what happened to that Errr Knobhead case? How come DD missed that topic? Lol..

Uski to khul ke leli
T- Whats there to discuss lol

Missing
Community Angel
0
31584
516

Not sure if central government fixes this share
From the things I was taught in school—The central government collects the state’s share of tax combined with its own share and then gives the states their share back
So its purely dependent on the amount collected on behalf of up which they are getting back
As the population is high there, tax collection is also high and consequently public expenditure should also be high

Not sure if this is right or not, but I understood this only from my accounts teacher

Missing
Deal Cadet
102
571
8
getready wrote:

Not sure if this fair or unfair but this came from INC Social media head
Its like sharing stuff coming from Arnab Goswami or Amit Malviya ..some posts might have credibility/good intentions but majority are politically motivated

Let me stick to taxes in this thread. If i talk politics, ppl will ask admin to move to political section  triumph

Missing
Deal Cadet
102
571
8
androgame wrote:

Not sure if central government fixes this share
From the things I was taught in school—The central government collects the state’s share of tax combined with its own share and then gives the states their share back
So its purely dependent on the amount collected on behalf of up which they are getting back
As the population is high there, tax collection is also high and consequently public expenditure should also be high

Not sure if this is right or not, but I understood this only from my accounts teacher

Yes bro. Seeing Bihar in 2nd place. Top 4 in the list are the most under developed states it appears. So may be this is different tax share. Not sure how they are allocated.

Missing