FAQ: How is FPD selected?

FAQ: How is FPD selected?

Score: 31 Votes: 40
Score: 31 Votes: 40
Score: 31 Votes: 40
Score: 31 Votes: 40
Score: 31 Votes: 40
Jimish4
Admin
9
875
12146
1089

Hello guys,

With community growing larger, there will always be mis-understandings and accusations. We wanted to communicate with the community more openly and freely to learn more on what we can do better and also clear misconceptions, if any. I hope, this FAQ will allow you to know more about the process involved in selecting deals for Front Page.

We are striving to make our Front Page deals to be extremely awesome from Day 1, so the community gets the maximum benefit. Its our commitment, that Front page deals will be genuinely “awesome”. We may have not succeeded many times but we hope that we have improved.

How are Front Page Deals selected?
  • Deals are posted and voted by users like you.
  • Every day, we (Admin Team and Moderators) go through the list of deals posted and collect an initial list of deals to be discussed further.
  • Admin Team also puts forwards the front page suggestions received via “Suggest as FP” feature.
  • Each deal is then individually researched by Moderators and Admin Team. We use data from past deals, google for more information to confirm that the price is indeed the lowest and also look at votes. Users comments are also carefully studied and each moderator or admin puts forward their view. This is done in Admin/Mods Forum.
  • After the discussion and stamp of approval of community and couple of moderators, the deal is promoted to Front Page.
Who does the research? Who decides to promote
  • Moderators and Admin team does the research. We use all possible tools we have at hand. With 5 moderators joining us, our research team has grown from 2 people to 7 people. Sometimes, some deals may have a lot of thumbs up even though the discount is merely 10% (eg: Mobile recharge or flight tickets). Such deals may also be promoted even if the savings may not be large but there is a huge demand for such discount.
  • If there is a general consensus that the deal should be promoted to Front Page, then the deal is promoted. General consensus means that there is a majority approval.
Why are deals hand-picked?
  • Deals are hand-picked since we believe that deals require significant research. Merely number of votes or clicks is not a good measure for deal popularity.
  • Also there maybe obvious price mistakes which may receive many votes, but are often cancelled by merchants. Such deals are skipped from our selection process.
  • Also there maybe certain deals, where we might be requested by merchants, to not promote it. So such deals are skipped too.
Only Reputable Merchants are listed
  • We do consider the general reputation of the merchant, when promoting a deal.We owe responsibility to our users to ensure that new users are protected from shoddy merchants.
  • Let me be clear that a merchant does not become less reputed if a price mistake or misuse of coupon was not honored.
Are you getting paid for Front page deals? Can I bribe you?
  • We do not accept any payment for promotion of deal as Front Page Deal. Let me be clear that we dont accept upfront payment for promotion of deal as Front Page deal. We have been approached by many merchants to push their deals as Front Page Deal but we have refused to accept any such offers, every single time.
  • We may receive a small commission for few (not all) products from Front Page deals but such commission does not influence our decision in any way.
  • The deal has to be approved by the community and then the moderators and Admin Team. So, there is no way to influence the process.
What shit are you talking? I see a Front page deal with negative votes
  • We do not lock thread from voting after a deal becomes a Front Page Deal.
  • We do our due diligence for such deals too. But sometimes users votes down a deal, after it comes on Front page, saying that its good but not FPD material.
  • We hope that with growing community and increasing participation, we will get better every day.
What about Featured and Exclusive deals? What about ads?
  • The Featured or exclusive deals does not go through the rigorous selection process.
I am a badge holder / moderator/ I am senior member / I am king of chinchpokli, do I get special preference

Your first post may be FPD and even after posting thousand posts, you might not get FPD. There is no special preference given to anyone and all deals will be selected purely on merit.

So ok all of this is fine, but do you guys promise that you will never go wrong?

We will try our best not to go wrong, but being mere mortals we might go wrong. But hopefully those instances would be few and far apart. You can also influence our decision by sending us 2 FPD alerts every day. We hope you will help us in being perfect https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif

We will always stick to our commitment for Front Page deals on home page. We have been following the above guidelines and we hope this gives you confidence and assurance that you are looking at really good deals on Front Page.

PS: You are welcome to comment and ask sensible questions but dont try to create nuisance or just thread crap… Such posts would be ignored or deleted.

FPD Suggested By > dealsnatcher ,
39 Comments  |  
28 Dimers
J6
Shopping Friend
15
199
11090
320

wow admin that was good, i never know that u go through such rigorous process to select fpd, all i was thinking was u just count popularity in to account, thanks for clearing the air , i should say one thing though i saved big on fpds, so cheers for ur efforts

10625141 343536905808779 3320206118963725486 n
Deal Captain
16
223
10508
251

i already knew this and i have never criticized against it

Daily%20bonanza
Deal Hunter
25
116
6352
181

fpd selection based on votes

have a friend circle on dd

votes up for each others deals!!!

everyone happy

many a times it become FPD

bcoz 90% of people vote up only they see the deals which are already voted up

and they vote down if the deal is already voted down!!!

Dex
Analyst
32
1,479
2910
102

Thanks admin..for such nice description…

I have few questions?

1. Do you measure deals in absolute terms or magnitude wise?.. I mean, say, there should be atlest 20-30% discount in price when compated to other sites.
2. What about errors and cancellations?? Eg. Suppose a deal is made FPD, later found that it was pricing error by website. What happens in that case?
3. What about good deals of no public interest? Cant they be made as FPDs? Eg. Price is pretty much less\good compared to other sites, but junta is not interested in that deal and no response from them, what happens then?

ad bot
1
1
1
1
Ad Bot

I found this sponsored content on one of the ad networks.

Dex
Analyst
32
1,479
2910
102
D!LY [email protected]@ wrote:@

fpd selection based on votes

have a friend circle on dd

votes up for each others deals!!!

everyone happy

many a times it become FPD

bcoz 90% of people vote up only they see the deals which are already voted up

and they vote down if the deal is already voted down!!!


Yepp..you are perfectly right…there is every chance of doing this…i feel it happened in some cases…admin should do cleat investigation and should have a deep look and also anticipate them…

Jimish4
Admin
9
875
12146
1089

@Popeye – Sure, here it goes:

1. We do look at discount % compared to other sites, but there is no fixed threshold. For some products even 5% extra discount may be considered awesome…
2. We try not to promote obvious price mistakes. Some are not very obvious. In such case, we then mark the deal as expired.
3. If the OP presents a considerable research behind such deals, we surely consider them. Picking such deals always may be difficult for us but we try not to miss them.

Jimish4
Admin
9
875
12146
1089

@anshu – So are you making a statement?? Or suggesting people to do that? https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_eek.gif

I said it earlier. If you are here to thread crap, this is not the right thread or even the right forum or website, to be frank. If it was a question or observation/doubt:

People who votes for deals also looks at who is posting the deal. If the one who posts deals have always been genuine every time, such users may get more attention. If you see deals which gets more attention, you will observe that it includes detailed price comparison, proper title and product description and so on.

Atleast internally, we do not promote a deal, if a crap deal has 5 thumbs up… So for us, it does not matter who votes but we do take FP suggestions seriously…

There are many newbies who gets their first deal as FP deal. So they have lots of friends too here?? Hopefully, with more constructive members, we hope that such groupism will go ahead, if there is any.

@sparctus – True, we said we try our best to reach 100% and we hope we achieve that soon.

Boom
Deal Subedar
1
107
1598
124

bq.Only Reputable Merchants are listed

What about greendust? They never got positive reviews

Speedracermovie
Deal Newbie
2
95
20
9

thnx for sharing the info https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif

Flower
Deal Subedar
6
21
1478
114

This will surely clear all the doubts if any….

Green design
Deal Captain
7
52
8240
217

@ admin

could u also post a thread that defines a repost on DD? would be great if u could do that as we dont have a clear definition now

Images
Deal Lieutenant
32
50
3399
55

I liked the “king of chinchpokli” part https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif

Daily%20bonanza
Deal Hunter
25
116
6352
181

i m nt saying that only those people got FPD who have friends

if the deal is too good it will be FPD

bt in many cases we have seen tha

you r right ab the genuine such users may get more attention

bt im suggesting here people to vote

cmon every one
just click up if you like the deal
dnt wait anyone else to do so:-}

Missing
Deal Lieutenant
18
49
5130
62

Thanks admin!!

B56d56fbcf04df0dd8d34eacc1542e81
Deal Subedar
3
252
1742
108
https://cdn2.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif
Ecg principle fast
Deal Cadet
0
139
812
65

Good one!!!this cleared all doubts!!!

Qwerty1
Super Moderator
15
638
14564
266

Score:9
Votes:16

Why are people voting down this??

Enrique iglesias3
Perfectionist
24
24
5756
119
Qwerty wrote:

Score:9
Votes:16

h1. Why are people voting down this??


Enable the “Show Voters” feature so that one can know who is voting which way.

Half life 2   gordon freeman
Tech Guru
36
46
17086
454
Are you getting paid for Front page deals? Can I bribe you?
We do not accept any payment for promotion of deal as Front Page Deal. Let me be clear that we dont accept upfront payment for promotion of deal as Front Page deal. We have been approached by many merchants to push their deals as Front Page Deal but we have refused to accept any such offers, every single time.
We may receive a small commission for few (not all) products from Front Page deals but such commission does not influence our decision in any way.
The deal has to be approved by the community and then the moderators and Admin Team. So, there is no way to influence the process.


this is a very good point. This will ensure that we get true / genuine fpds and not deals bribed by some sites….more like the lokpal

Graphics riders 536941 1
Deal Newbie
0
57
23
13

nice post admin thanks,
i think these points should always be emailed to any dimer newbie who join our community and ofcourse can be emailed to all the existing members so that all their doubts about FPD get cleared and then no one will beg for FPD, dimers will come to know that any deal which is worth and satisfying required criteria for FPD will get FPD, thats it.
regards.

Rain
Blogger
2
324
5592
197

well , u people seriously need to re read wat all stuff u wrote…many garbage deals ,garbage in the sense ( one or more than one reason(s) may hold valid)
1. huge discount from mrp and probably lowest one but bad reviews of the product.
2.margin of hardly 5%-10% from nxt lowest is fpd but for another product margin of 20% is not an fpd..(hypothetical figure).
3. despite many suggestions n green votes, and even if product goes oss, the deal does not stand anywhr near front page.
4. if futurebazaar 100 rs on 101 is fpd then no one else will get credit evn for posting link of iPhone 5 listed at rs 101 (hypothetical case) ..but why?

assuming admin is blindly trusting mods for fpd selection then its time for admin to re-evaluate their judgement capability.

and in case if admin is also involved then it seems its time to share deals via whatsapp or emails instead of dd.

PS :
1.I dont care a damn for this fpd credit or karma system.They do not value anything in real world.
2.I dont even get 1% of what dd earns through my links.
3. Please don’t give me lollipop of Dimes system.

Rain
Blogger
2
324
5592
197

and one more thing..u gotta create a new forum..deals which deserves to be fpd but it beeds to be evaluated if it holds true..

like the current pantech phone ( i am not aiming on deal posted as i myself have purchased one and this is my first purchase on global easy buy ) ..well,that deal is a real good deal considering ebay ,seller feedback, and product features..

but since nobody have yet received under this from that seller hence i wud say its too early to promote it to fpd..instead there should b another section mentioning this deal is good but not yet sure whether wether it will turn out sweet or not..but it shud deserve same respect as of fpd..

Rain
Blogger
2
324
5592
197

sweet in the sense 60-70% buyers received product in good shape and satisfied …satisfied does nt emply over expectation…

Draw
Deal Colonel
10
1,179
52036
1044
tusharsethi90935 wrote:

well , u people seriously need to re read wat all stuff u wrote…many garbage deals ,garbage in the sense ( one or more than one reason(s) may hold valid)

and in case if admin is also involved then it seems its time to share deals via whatsapp or emails instead of dd.

PS :
1.I dont care a damn for this fpd credit or karma system.They do not value anything in real world.
2.I dont even get 1% of what dd earns through my links.
3. Please don’t give me lollipop of Dimes system.


Jimish4
Admin
9
875
12146
1089

An Important Note:

If the deal does not contain price of the item, then it wont be considered for FPD. It has become a common nuisance with Homeshop18 superdeals.. Actual price is never updated in the original post and other perfectly valid posts gets marked as reposts. So, from now on, for such types of deals where price is unknown, the first accurate post will get the credit. So it does not simply become a rat race and dimers/visitors are able to find the best price…

Rain
Blogger
2
324
5592
197
Admin wrote:

h1. An Important Note:

If the deal does not contain price of the item, then it wont be considered for FPD. It has become a common nuisance with Homeshop18 superdeals.. Actual price is never updated in the original post and other perfectly valid posts gets marked as reposts. So, from now on, for such types of deals where price is unknown, the first accurate post will get the credit. So it does not simply become a rat race and dimers/visitors are able to find the best price…


Admin ji, if a deal gets many vu and fpd suggestions from high post dimers, without any price comparison it must be assumed that this deal might be good or atleast worth looking..

Jimish4
Admin
9
875
12146
1089
tusharsethi90935 wrote:

Admin wrote:

h1. An Important Note:

If the deal does not contain price of the item, then it wont be considered for FPD. It has become a common nuisance with Homeshop18 superdeals.. Actual price is never updated in the original post and other perfectly valid posts gets marked as reposts. So, from now on, for such types of deals where price is unknown, the first accurate post will get the credit. So it does not simply become a rat race and dimers/visitors are able to find the best price…


Admin ji, if a deal gets many vu and fpd suggestions from high post dimers, without any price comparison it must be assumed that this deal might be good or atleast worth looking..


And obviously we do that…. Just attaching a screenshot so it gives an idea on how many posts we have internally to just discuss this FP:

https://links.desidime.com?ref=forums&url=https://i.imgur.com/OsY5N.png

But still we have not achieved perfection https://cdn1.desidime.com/assets/textile-editor/icon_smile.gif

Missing