Want your valuable opinion...please do contribute your POV

Although I often notice you jumping to quick conclusions without giving proper thought or knowing the whole story, I agree with your thoughts here.

It’s totally wrong to hog so many codes intentionally and then do a giveaway when you are not able to trade. I guess this is why some traders gave me their remaining codes to giveaway to other dimers rather than doing it themselves. It helped them avoid taking the heat themselves. I fell for it thinking that it’s better to giveaway than to let the codes go to waste because of someone’s laziness so I complied. But now I know better. Will decline such requests in the future.

Ref: http://www.desidime.com/forums/request-giveaway...

CC @dimeryo

Kisi ko kuch bhi nahi bolana hai?

@thrifty_indian wrote:

Kisi ko kuch bhi nahi bolana hai?

bro enjoy /

@forgotten wrote:

@thrifty_indian wrote:

Kisi ko kuch bhi nahi bolana hai?

bro enjoy /

HAhaha… valuable suggestion. Bura mat bolo, bura mat suno, bura mat dekho. Just Enjoy.

Baat mai dum hai…..
What we can do?
we can’t stop him or anyone from generating codes

Dear Fellow Indian,
No denying you are correct but as you have rightly pointed dog chasing a car seems useless to you but what about the dog? Are you sure about him the usefulness of his act? May be for dog it is a way to fulfilling his ego. Now the morality of the act you poited out, It is a know fact when people are given ways to hide themselves they will do the things that are morally wrong. Internet provide them a way to conceal the identify hence the action.

P.S. Still appears the chemical locha. Over n Out.

"@fhpitv":http://www.desidime.com/users/459303 wrote:

This reply is still under myderation. Your patience for few hours greatly appreciated.

Is it a self made post? Only one person can do that

“@CrazyTroll ":http://www.desidime.com/users/...34 wrote:

Dear Fellow Indian,
No denying you are correct but as you have rightly pointed dog chasing a car seems useless to you but what about the dog? Are you sure about him the usefulness of his act? May be for dog it is a way to fulfilling his ego. Now the morality of the act you poited out, It is a know fact when people are given ways to hide themselves they will do the things that are morally wrong. Internet provide them a way to conceal the identify hence the action.


P.S. Still appears the chemical locha. Over n Out.

I have already been brandished ‘rude’ so I am refraining from commenting. Just observing others POV. Appreciate yours too.

Instead of generating so many codes he should have left it for others to generate. But it was still good as he was sharing them in pm rather than posting openly as it is waste of everyone’s time. The other day a guy shared 500+ freecharge codes openly. Out of those codes so many might have been waste as nobody has time to check for unused codes among 100’s of codes.

Such acts do benefit the users I am not talking the intension of the one who generates so many codes)

1) These offers usually are there for short period of time(a thing in which this act contributes)

2) Many users (usually, including me) would try to loot atleast the codes that he can use…..say (10.-15, friends family,chacha chachi, mausi,mausa ,bhaiya,bhauji, jija , sala and their duplicate accounts )

3) The offer is over in a few hours.

4) One who arrives after 24 hours gets Babaji ka Thullu

5) Now this user who captured 1000 codes…(had a major hand in offer being over) distributes the code by PMing with the condition one for each.(He Shouldn’t post it openly…that cause more loss than gain….as Many people don’t get the code and waste huge time)

6) 5 does lead to equitable distribution. Had he not done his act somewhere around 100 users (taking that each dimer on an avg try to capture 10)would have benefited , now the number is 1000.
(however that does make others dependent on him a fact i don’t like)

@thrifty_indian wrote:

Kisi ko kuch bhi nahi bolana hai?

VU
Wasting their own time generating codes by which they are obstructing others to get benefitted.
If its some secret source then generating codes (as many as they can) isn’t a mistake if the intention is to giveaway the codes to the needy, but exploiting an open source is too bad.
Whatever we can’t blame them completely, i’ll go with 50:50 as they are supernatural and are able to grab “N” no. of coupons whereas normal people couldn’t

@gaurav9656 wrote:

Such acts do benefit the users I am not talking the intension of the one who generates so many codes)

1) These offers usually are there for short period of time(a thing in which this act contributes)

2) Many users (usually, including me) would try to loot atleast the codes that he can use…..say (10.-15, friends family,chacha chachi, mausi,mausa ,bhaiya,bhauji, jija , sala and their duplicate accounts )

3) The offer is over in a few hours.

4) One who arrives after 24 hours gets Babaji ka Thullu

5) Now this user who captured 1000 codes…(had a major hand in offer being over) distributes the code by PMing with the condition one for each.(He Shouldn’t post it openly…that cause more loss than gain….as Many people don’t get the code and waste huge time)

6) 5 does lead to equitable distribution. Had he not done his act somewhere around 100 users (taking that each dimer on an avg try to capture 10)would have benefited , now the number is 1000.
(however that does make others dependent on him a fact i don’t like)

Agree with #2 and #4.

and

Now this user who captured 1000 codes…(had a major hand in offer being over)

P.S. There are ample number of small giveaways. I myself gave away 3 out of 6 FC 100% CB codes which I generated for myself left unused.

@thrifty_indian wrote:

@gaurav9656 wrote:

Such acts do benefit the users I am not talking the intension of the one who generates so many codes)

1) These offers usually are there for short period of time(a thing in which this act contributes)

2) Many users (usually, including me) would try to loot atleast the codes that he can use…..say (10.-15, friends family,chacha chachi, mausi,mausa ,bhaiya,bhauji, jija , sala and their duplicate accounts )

3) The offer is over in a few hours.

4) One who arrives after 24 hours gets Babaji ka Thullu

5) Now this user who captured 1000 codes…(had a major hand in offer being over) distributes the code by PMing with the condition one for each.(He Shouldn’t post it openly…that cause more loss than gain….as Many people don’t get the code and waste huge time)

6) 5 does lead to equitable distribution. Had he not done his act somewhere around 100 users (taking that each dimer on an avg try to capture 10)would have benefited , now the number is 1000.
(however that does make others dependent on him a fact i don’t like)

Agree with #2 and #4.

and

Now this user who captured 1000 codes…(had a major hand in offer being over)

P.S. There are ample number of small giveaways. I myself gave away 3 out of 6 FC 100% CB codes which I generated for myself left unused.

Would definitely like a comment on 5,6
Edit : Missed the PS…. But the ample r not ample enough….

Me too did same, Am I wrong ??

@gaurav9656 wrote:

But the ample r not ample enough….

The same might be said about the equitable distribution.

@G33kBoyRavi wrote:

Me too did same, Am I wrong ??

Who am I to judge right or wrong? Read what others have to say about it and you decide for yourself.

@thrifty_indian wrote:

@G33kBoyRavi wrote:

Me too did same, Am I wrong ??

Who am I to judge right or wrong? Read what others have to say about it and you decide for yourself.

Who are others to Judge Me or anyone else?? Some like Idli some like Dhosa, everyone has got their own views so don’t read reviews. Those codes were useless for you so you created separate thread to describe it, but not for all. Giveaway is never a bad idea, who cares if he looted 1000 codes or full site.

@G33kBoyRavi wrote:

@thrifty_indian wrote:

@G33kBoyRavi wrote:

Me too did same, Am I wrong ??

Who am I to judge right or wrong? Read what others have to say about it and you decide for yourself.

Who are others to Judge Me or anyone else?? Some like Idli some like Dhosa, everyone has got their own views so don’t read reviews. Those codes were useless for you so you created separate thread to describe it, but not for all. Giveaway is never a bad idea, who cares if he looted 1000 codes or full site.

I disagree with your view but chalo tumne apna point rakha hai acchi baat hai.

@thrifty_indian wrote:

@gaurav9656 wrote:

But the ample r not ample enough….

The same might be said about the equitable distribution.

Yes… but i think 1k is better to 3-5 X10-20 giveaway threads … Had he posted them in open then it would have caused mayhem, wastage of time (by trying to use used codes ) and codes(as vinay pointed out) and
Equitable distribution would also have failed…

@gaurav9656 wrote:

@thrifty_indian wrote:

@gaurav9656 wrote:

But the ample r not ample enough….

The same might be said about the equitable distribution.

Yes… but i think 1k is better to 3-5 X10-20 giveaway threads … Had he posted them in open then it would have caused mayhem, wastage of time (by trying to use used codes ) and codes(as vinay pointed out) and
Equitable distribution would also have failed…

I would like re-visit one point that you mentioned that the code expires/over within hours if not minutes because of such rampant mis-loot. So, how is it going to be any useful to anyone? As I remember very well, about the ebay sms codes, I generated 5-6 codes to be used at night when am totally free of other responsibilities but sadly the codes ‘expired’ by that time. If you re-visit that thread you would know why. Just a handful looted and others were left high and dry.

@thrifty_indian wrote:


I wouldn’t have objected but certain someone(he has forbidden me to tag) said I am rude.


Kisi ko kuch bhi nahi bolana hai?

Ha kehna hai mere ko ki aap bahot rude ho

@G33kBoyRavi wrote:

Me too did same, Am I wrong ??

You are the right person to answer !! " Why you do that ? "

@thrifty_indian wrote:

I would like re-visit one point that you mentioned that the code expires/over within hours if not minutes because of such rampant mis-loot. So, how is it going to be any useful to anyone? As I remember very well, about the ebay sms codes, I generated 5-6 codes to be used at night when am totally free of other responsibilities but sadly the codes ‘expired’ by that time. If you re-visit that thread you would know why. Just a handful looted and others were left high and dry.

EDIT : I meant code generation process and not the code themselves

With Ebay Yes I agree you are correct…but unike ebay and nowadays Paytm others (Like Freecharge, Sorry if its limited info I am not much into using variety of sites and offers) usually don’t expire the already generated codes before expiry time.

Ideally a site should never expire a code before the mentioned expiry time.

@gaurav9656 wrote:


EDIT : I meant code generation process and not the code themselves

With Ebay Yes I agree you are correct…but unike ebay and nowadays Paytm others (Like Freecharge, Sorry if its limited info I am not much into using variety of sites and offers) usually don’t expire the already generated codes before expiry time.

Ideally a site should never expire a code before the mentioned expiry time.

Generally, a site like eBay sets up a counter for which they lift it up when the maximum redemption has reached out so no use of as many codes u have generated, its purely on FCFS basis. Recently, PayU withdrew all his offer before the said time after seeing massive misuse of their coupons by the same users again and again. As @Achilles bro has said exploiting the system code is not good and by the time these companies will come up with high security and lot of restriction, juz think what would happen then.

PS: I m not preaching here but if u have generated many codes for whatever the reason u had, pls make sure to distribute them among needy only.

@Gr@h@m@lkene™ wrote:


Generally, a site like eBay sets up a counter for which they lift it up when the maximum redemption has reached out so no use of as many codes u have generated, its purely on FCFS basis. Recently, PayU withdrew all his offer before the said time after seeing massive misuse of their coupons by the same users again and again. As @Achilles bro has said exploiting the system code is not good and by the time these companies will come up with high security and lot of restriction, juz think what would happen then.

PS: I m not preaching here but if u have generated many codes for whatever the reason u had, pls make sure to distribute them among needy only.

we are kind of saying the same thing….
except i do feel when its code generation counter should always be at the code gen facility and not redemption…..
rai baat misuse ki…if there’s a loophole people would use it….Greed triumphs propriety (Come on man how would CAs,Lawyers survive) and the companies wud keep on rectifying/filling the gaps.

EDIT : Single code single user giveaway kind of takes care of your PS concern